Green Tomato Pasta Sauce

Be sure to use that glut of green tomatoes at the end of the summer season for good use! You will appreciate bottles of Green Tomato Pasta Sauce come winter.

Not all green tomatoes will ripen on the vine nor windowsill. Some stubbornly will remain green as the cooler weather hits. As you may have already read, raw green tomatoes aren’t advisable to eat due to their tannin however, once cooked, they are most delicious.

If you have had your fair share of fried green tomatoes, or prepared a bountiful supply of Green Tomato & Chilli Chutney you may wish to turn your abundant harvest into a Green Tomato Pasta Sauce!

PLEASE NOTE: As this recipe doesn’t include vinegar in the ingredients list (as you would imagine for a chutney or relish) it’s important that the jars are 100% sealed with both sterilised jars and lids. If the lids don’t ‘pop’ and indent once cooled down, I highly recommend you then use the Water Bath Method  for any jars that didn’t quite seal as you’d like. It’s not as difficult as it may sound and I have found it results in a 100% success rate.

You can cook this pasta sauce in a large saucepan on the stove top, or you could throw all the ingredients into a slow cooker on low for a few hours. As the mixture is blended before bottling, it doesn’t actually matter so much how you cook it but ensure that the pot is covered as you don’t want to reduce it down too much.

At the end of the bottling process, you’ll read that you squeeze some lemon juice on the top – it helps build a thin barrier to help hinder oxidisation and discolouration.

How do you use Green Tomato Pasta sauce?

Green tomatoes (by design) are both bitter and acidic. While the cooking process makes them edible, you may find the aftertaste too bitter for your liking. It has been suggested (and I well agree) that when it comes to using the pasta sauce:

  • you may wish to add it to a white or cheese sauce before serving – helping to smooth out some potentially sharp edges
  • dilute it with coconut milk, before heating and serving
  • or add a dollop of sour cream and/or a sprinkling of Parmesan cheese on top is tasty too.

green tomatoesGreen Tomato Pasta Sauce

Green Tomato Pasta Sauce

Ingredients

  • 2kg green tomatoes, chopped
  • 2 medium onions, chopped
  • 2 chilli, chopped
  • 5 cloves garlic, minced (optional)
  • 1/2 cup brown sugar
  • 2 tsp sea salt
  • 1 tsp cracked black pepper
  • 1 Tbsp dried mixed herbs
  • 2 bay leaves
  • lemon juice

Method

  1. Put everything into a large saucepan over medium heat. Bring to the boil then cover, stirring regularly. After 45-60 minutes the tomatoes will be soft.
  2. Remove the bay leaves, then using a stick blender (or food processor) blend the mix into a smooth sauce.
  3. Pour into sterilised jars, squeeze a layer of lemon juice onto the top of each preserve, then seal with a sterilised lid. If the lids don’t naturally pop and indent once cooled, use the Water Bath Method to ensure it seals properly, or alternatively keep the unsealed jars in your fridge.

Julie Legg - Rediscover
Julie Legg. Homesteader. DIY Enthusiast. Author. Actor. Musician. Curious Thinker. I’m a Kiwi with an insatiable curiosity for learning and rediscovering life’s treasures.

5 Comments

  1. rideaudrapé
    July 12, 2024

    I usually make Green tomato chutney and, the bitterness disappears after you leave it for 3 years in the jar………..

    Reply
  2. Olivia
    June 5, 2023

    I made this tonight and it had a very strange, bitter aftertaste. I tried adding more sugar and it reduced the aftertaste slightly. Could it have been the Roccoto chili I used? I think adding grilled cheese or a béchamel sauce would balance the flavour as a pasta sauce. It smelled lovely though so maybe it’ll be alright.

    Reply
    1. Julie Legg - Rediscover
      Julie
      June 18, 2023

      Hi Olivia, yes – green tomatoes will have a certain bitterness (a bit like green chilli), whereas the red ripened fruit has it’s own natural sweetness. I agree…adding a white sauce, or something cheesy would help carry the flavour and smooth off some bitter edges. >>Julie

      Reply
  3. suzanne
    April 9, 2023

    Thank you for this. I water bath something very similar but add curry powder to it and add coconut milk at reheating. I would have never thought to make a green pasta sauce and will try it this fall. Gonna poke around your sight now.

    Reply
    1. Julie Legg - Rediscover
      Julie
      April 11, 2023

      Thanks Suzanne, sounds a great idea too. Thanks for sharing. Good luck with your pasta sauce making! >>Julie

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top